Skip to main content
This page compares Bach with Inno Setup, NSIS and WiX (MSI) on one real app, and says what the numbers do and do not show. The scripts and raw results are in the bench folder of the repository, so you can run them on your own computer.
One computer (Intel Core i5-12400F, 15.7 GB of RAM, SSD, Windows 11 Home, Windows Defender on), one app, one run per setting. Treat the differences as a direction, not as exact figures.

The app

A real Electron application: the Electron 33.2.0 runtime plus the production node_modules of seven well-known packages. It has 10,107 files and weighs 355 MB. A second version (1.1.0) changes about 300 files, adds 60 and removes 40, so an update has real work to do. Every tool installs per user, silently, without administrator rights. The scripts are the plain ones a developer would write in an afternoon: default settings, no custom pages.

Speed

A first install is close to a tie: writing 10,000 files dominates, and NSIS was fastest. Updating is where Bach is far ahead, because setup skips files that already match the new version. The Inno and NSIS scripts here copy every file again.

Build time and size

Bach’s default build is the slowest to make and is not the smallest. Inno Setup and NSIS with their heaviest settings produce smaller files than anything Bach builds today. On a tiny app Bach adds about 9.4 MB for the window’s runtime; Inno Setup adds 1.9 MB, NSIS and MSI add nothing measurable.

When things go wrong

The Inno Setup and NSIS rows describe the plain scripts. A careful script author can add [InstallDelete] or explicit Delete lines and avoid deleting user files. The comparison shows what each tool does by default, not what is possible. The MSI keeps the old version intact through Windows Installer’s rollback. The price is a 136-second update and a 33-second removal.

What this does not show

  • Another app (many small files, or a few huge ones) moves the numbers.
  • Features were not scored. Inno Setup and NSIS have far more scripting power than Bach, and an MSI is what many IT departments deploy with Group Policy or Intune. Bach has one config file, a built-in updater and a modern window. Choose by what you need.
  • Bach’s figures come from this repository’s release build on the day of the run and will change as it does.
To reproduce the run, see bench/README.md. For moving an existing installer over, see Migrate from another installer.